Water heaters
Water heater repair and replacement in Fullerton
No hot water, a puddle by the tank or a heater that rumbles. Here is how to tell a repair from a replacement, and what a proper replacement in Fullerton involves.

Repair or replace?
What the symptom usually points to
| What you notice | Usually means | Usually |
|---|---|---|
| No hot water from a gas heater | Pilot out, a failed thermocouple or flame sensor, or a gas valve problem | Repair |
| Lukewarm water from an electric heater | One of the two heating elements or its thermostat has failed | Repair |
| Water dripping from the pipe on the side | The relief valve opened: too much pressure or heat, or the valve is worn | Repair, and find out why it opened |
| Rumbling or popping when it heats | Mineral scale has built up on the bottom of the tank | Flush if it is young; often a sign of age |
| Rusty hot water only | The tank lining is corroding from inside | Replace soon |
| Water seeping from the bottom of the tank | The tank itself has rusted through | Replace |
Why Fullerton heaters wear out early
The City describes its tap water as very hard, between 14 and 25 grains per gallon depending on the time of year. Heating hard water drops the minerals out as scale. In a tank it settles on the bottom, where it insulates the burner from the water and makes the heater work longer for the same hot shower. In a tankless unit it coats the heat exchanger and can trip error codes.
That is why the questions about flushing and softening below matter more here than in towns with soft water.
- Ask whether flushing the tank is still worthwhile. On an older heater that has never been flushed, it can loosen sediment that then clogs the drain valve.
- Tankless units need their heat exchanger descaled on a schedule. Ask how often, and whether they will show you how.
- A water softener slows scale in the heater and every fixture after it.
Choosing the replacement
Tank or tankless
A new tank heater
The simpler swap when the old heater is a tank in the same spot. Gas and vent connections usually stay as they are, though the plumber must check that the vent and the combustion air still meet code for the new unit.
- Keeps a store of hot water, so several showers in a row are fine until it runs out.
- Takes floor space in the garage, closet or yard cabinet.
- Needs earthquake straps and, in a garage, usually a raised stand for a gas model.
A tankless heater
Heats water as it flows, so it does not run out, but it has a limit on how many taps it can serve at once. A gas tankless unit often needs a larger gas line and a different vent than the tank it replaces.
- Hangs on a wall, inside or outside.
- Ask whether your gas meter and gas pipe can supply it; this is often what makes the job bigger.
- Ask about descaling, since Fullerton water is hard.
Rules that apply in Fullerton
Straps, permit and license
Earthquake straps
California law, Health and Safety Code section 19211, requires new, replacement and existing residential water heaters to be braced, anchored or strapped so they cannot topple or slide in an earthquake.
Permit
Fullerton's Building and Safety Division generally requires a permit when plumbing equipment is replaced. Ask the plumber whether they will pull it for your heater and book the inspection.
License
Water heater installation falls under California's C-36 plumbing license. Check the number on CSLB's license lookup before anyone starts.
What a full replacement includes
A replacement is more than setting a new tank where the old one stood. Expect the plumber to drain and remove the old heater, set the new one, reconnect water and gas or power, fit new straps, check the vent and the relief valve discharge pipe, then fill and fire it before leaving.
- Ask whether hauling the old heater away is included.
- Ask who handles the permit and when the inspection will be.
- Ask for the manufacturer's warranty paperwork and the model number in writing.
- If the heater is in a closet indoors, ask about a drain pan and where a leak would go.
If your heater is not working and you rent, tell the landlord first. A water heater in a rented home is normally the owner's to repair or replace.
Water heater questions
How long should a water heater last in Fullerton?
It varies with the model, how hard the water is and whether it was ever flushed. The label on the tank shows when it was made; ask the plumber how its condition compares with its age.
Is a leaking relief valve dangerous?
The valve is a safety device doing its job, or a worn valve dripping. Either way, do not cap or plug the pipe. Have a plumber find out why it opened.
Can I go from gas to an electric heat pump heater?
Often, but it may need a new electrical circuit and room for the unit to breathe. Ask the plumber what your house would need before you decide.
No hot water?
Say whether the heater is gas or electric, tank or tankless, and whether there is water on the floor.
Talk to a plumber about it
For a plumbing problem in a home in or near Fullerton: a leak, a clog, no hot water, a toilet, the sewer line.
Call (714) 555-0134Calls may be recorded. See how this referral service is paid and what happens to what you tell us.